The First Church of the Nazarene (Galesburg, Illinois) was organized and incorporated on June 20, 1920 with 10 charter members. It first met in a rented hall on the southeast corner of the public square (where the First Financial Bank is now).

Services were moved to the home of Charles Gooden, one of the charter members, at 762 E. Berrien street during the construction of their building which stands to this day on the corner of South and Pearl street. The new church was dedicated on November 21, 1920.
Rev. Charles A. Brown, District Superintendent, appointed Rev. Sheldon Kelly as the first pastor. Rev. Kelly later became president of Olivet Nazarene College.
Glen Braden, Claude Ruddell, Rev. Floyd Pounds, Wallace Alderson, Carl Stroops, and Jack Lee
helped to break ground on October 12, 1958 for a new church located at Elm and Webster streets. The cornerstone was set Sunday September 25, 1959 with the dedication following on June 5, 1960. The first service held at this location was on Thanksgiving Sunday November 21, 1959.

On October 1, 1978 ground was broken for new construction and on
September 2, 1979 the new sanctuary was occupied for the first time.
Galesburg First Church of the Nazarene Pastors:
Rev. Sheldon Kelly 1920
Rev. Clarence Matteson 1920
Rev. A.J. and Clara Laird 1921-1923
Rev. M.R. Fitch 1924
Rev. E.C. Dundas 1925
Rev. Eva Butler 1926-1927
Rev. Earl Stevens 1927-1928
Dr. Nelson Giles 1929
Pastor Anna Branch 1930-1931
Rev. O.E. Nelson 1932-1933
Rev. W.E. Crossman 1934-1935
Rev. Paul Lee 1936-1940
Rev. E.C. Hester 1941-1943
Rev. Harold Bedinger 1944-1947
Rev. Charles Downs 1948-1956
Rev. R.H. Canfield 1957
Rev. Floyd Pounds 1957-1968
Rev. Gerald Parker 1968-1972
Rev. Floyd Suman 1972-1975
Rev. James E. Hazelwood 1975-1995
Rev. Wayland Stewart 1995-1999
Rev. Ron Scarlett 2000-present